web components are still very flawed, they completely ignore a slew of problems, and still promote tons of global variables which is just a major no no. Some of the features that come along with the web component spec are fantastic, but the way they're doing it is quite wrong IMO, and it cant really be done right from a browser point of view really, the bulk of this should still be user-land, I find it a little scary that browser vendors are already "accepting" these sort of half-complete concepts as what's coming next, we dont need more broken tools
Agreed. It's frightening to see people embrace web components while completely ignoring the usability issues, and adopting the attitude of "develop first, think about API design later."
The folks behind web components are super open to feedback. I'd be happy to introduce you so you can provide some feedback on where the spec should go to better address the pain points you have.
Do you know how they'll tie into ES6 modules? (if at all), that's definitely a big concern for me, I'd like to never see a global again as far as libraries go. Anyway yeah that would be great! I totally understand the end goal of having something usable out of the box, I'm just not 100% convinced browsers can even really get away with that. There's still fundamental issues like dependency mapping and manifests etc that are purely user-land anyway, so at the end of the day they wouldn't really be useful without some sort of registry/packaging mechanism anyway
