This is a good example where downvoting, provided this is the rationale, is a poor decision. Why not just comment? Even if it is a simple note. Honest question. Not trying to weigh in on this partcular subject per-se, but this comment makes it seem like its normal course practice on HN. (disclosure: & I just upovoted TZS, for raising his hand on this).
I too find most down votes distasteful. In fact, I use a custom style sheet to color down voted comments red so I can see them, and unless I can find no redeeming value whatsoever in the comment I give it an up vote to counter the down votes.
In this particular case, however, I think the down votes were fine, because the comment:
1. grossly misstated facts, by attributing George Roedler's statements to Larry Pogemiller,
2. is essentially just a rant calling for Pogemiller's head.
