Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Indeed. In a functional society the district attorney would decline to prosecute as there is no benefit to society in going after a public urinator, streaker, or sexting teenage couple. But here in the US a politician has to be "tough on crime" or work for the "benefit of the children".


True, however, most prosecutors are trying to get high conviction rates, and don't care about the good to society.


Wouldn't that deter prosecutors from going after relatively minor crimes that are less likely to lead to a conviction?


Not really, a plea bargain resulting in any punishment at all counts as a conviction for the prosecutor. A case like CP or cocaine possession which are in most jurisdictions basically straight liability crimes are very nearly guaranteed convictions. Plus, it never looks bad for a prosecutor to have convicted a child pornographer when it comes time to run for re-election. And not prosecuting such a case would lead to ads run against you saying that you're soft on child rapists.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: