Training generative ML tools is qualitatively different from showing on website, even if both are technically “derivative works”, so this is a massive bait-and-switch. Is it the first time something is acceptable by the letter of pre-existing law but not the spirit?
> Is it the first time something is acceptable by the letter of pre-existing law but not the spirit?
Well .. no. It happens each time that Google et. al find a new way to use your data. It's what all we German "privacy nuts" have warned people about for years and the reason that the older German data protection laws and now EU regulations require you to state exactly what you are doing with data ("purpose limitation"). If companies can just write "oh well, we will use it for something" how can anyone evaluate whether they should accept without knowing the future? Right. They cant.
So, this could be another case of the EU kicking Facebook in the face. We'll see.
