Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A cashless society is also a society where there is no longer any anonymity

This is what concerns me the most. I think most of what this article proposes is great, but knowing that absolutely everything I buy can be traced back to me makes me uncomfortable.



The OP article didn't mention it by other articles on the same topic did: http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-202_162-57399610/sweden-moving-t...

> Banhof, says a digital economy also raises privacy issues because of the electronic trail of transactions. He supports the idea of phasing out cash, but says other anonymous payment methods need to be introduced instead.

> "One should be able to send money and donate money to different organizations without being traced every time," he says.


Whatever one may think of systems like ecash or bitcoin, it's disappointing to see a journalist writing as if nothing like that has even been conceived.


As has been said many times before, Bitcoin is not anonymous either. It is at best weakly pseudonymous.

Where Bitcoin does improve over the centralised system described is that you cannot arbitrarily lock someone out of Bitcoin.


I expect that tracking every single transaction would be a great deterrent to corruption, theft, and tax evasion. On the other hand, a lot of corruption, theft and tax evasion already occurs with electronic payments.


Perhaps this assumption is wrong. Is it really impossible to create an electronic currency that guarantees anonymity?


No? Money simply has a signature. The major reason why cash is "anonymous" is because there is no attempt to track the serials beyond initial deliveries to financial institutions, etc. Money already is simply pseudonymous; if, for example, we tracked serial numbers during transactions, you'd be trackable unless you exchanged currency outside of a bill reader setup.

But this is true of electronic systems as well. I could just as easily give you an SD card with $1,000 on it and the tracking system would fail rapidly.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: