Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's just not safe. It's unusable. you can't ask it normal questions to not get stonewalled by it's default censorship message - it wouldn't even work for commercial case.


Seems fine for most commercial use cases. Got a tech support chat bot? It doesn't need to be answering questions about religion. Also, corporate environments already tend to be super politically correct. There's already a long list of normal words I can't say at work.


Can you post that list here?


No can do, but https://developers.google.com/style/word-list seems to have all of them and more, except that it's missing "hooray." One funny red-exclamation-mark example from this public list is "smartphone."

Some are recommended against just cause of spelling or something, but anything that says to use a more "precise" term seems to mean it's considered offensive, kinda like in The Giver.


Here's another one: https://s.wsj.net/public/resources/documents/stanfordlanguag...

BTW hooray is okay there, but 'hip-hip-hooray is discouraged. Germans said hep hep in the hep-hep pogrom of the early 1800s and might have said 'hep hep hurra' during the 3rd Reich. It cuts too closely though, personally I just use bravo to avoid any trouble.


At least Stanford's rules were retracted.

About hip hip, I ended up looking into that when I saw it back then. The connection to the early 1800s riots was made by a single journalist back then, and it was most likely false. More importantly, nobody really makes that connection unless they're trying to.


Adhering to that list seems exhausting…


I wholly disagree. This is arguably close to the perfect solution:

- Developers and end users can choose which model they want to use

- Model distributors don't necessarily take the fall since they provide a "healthy" model alternative

- The uncensored "base" model can be finetuned into whatever else is needed

You have to remember, ChatGPT is censored like a Soviet history book but didn't struggle to hit hundreds of millions of users in months. This is what releases will look like from now on, and it's not even a particularly damning example.


I saw them as demos rather than finished products. Kinda like, "Look, you can chat tune these if you want to."




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: