Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Bad news, it’s already over “your sky” because it’s how LEO works.

> Fibre should be rolled out for internet access, not another unsensible Musk dream

You want to roll fiber through national forests and parks to serve a few rural people? How do you prefer the ocean faring population to get access?



> How do you prefer the ocean faring population to get access?

Just get one of those big rolls of fiber they use to lay undersea cables and let it unwind as you sail. Mmm, terabits per second!


Why does it have to go through the parks? And radio towers work just as well, it doesn't have to be a satellite hundreds of kilometres up in the sky. Ships already have access to internet through satellites already, there doesn't have to be even more

EDIT. I meant why does the fibre have to through parks as a reason for having starlink


The constallations are spread for coverage and are in low earth orbits for signal strength, like sharks they have to stay in motion .. and many of the orbits are "precessing" .. they go about the earth and that great circle "ring" itself is turning - physics dictates that they go over all the surface sooner or later.

The SKA proposal is that comms constellation satellites switch themselves off (stop transmitting) when over the S.African and W.Australian SKA exclusion zones.


Other satellites and ground-based radio towers do as much damage to the abilities of the Square Kilometre Array and other radio astronomy as Starlink.


People who claim the satellite internet on ships now is good enough are as ignorant as people who claim dial-up is good enough.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: