Obviously it’s all a matter of taste but there are people (myself included) that think practical effects complemented with CGI is still the right way to do action.
Top Gun Maverick would be a data point that a lot of people agree. No matter how good the CGI, actors con a sound stage in front of a green screen just behave differently than actors or stunt people actually doing action stuff.
Well, to be fair, if you filmed yourself in a car, with a windshield-attached camera, driving over rough terrain, and then stabilized the footage, it would also look like you and other passengers lurching around - though perhaps in a more synchronized fashion.
In that footage you'd be at least moving in similar directions, in st they're all over the place, it's just way more obvious when there's no camera shake.
Top Gun Maverick would be a data point that a lot of people agree. No matter how good the CGI, actors con a sound stage in front of a green screen just behave differently than actors or stunt people actually doing action stuff.