Like I said earlier, how about keeping your own side of the bargain?
Remember the 'useless' chef already got you to where you are presently. The place where you need to raise more money.
Why then did you hire the chef in the first place? If the chef has started cooking poorly, you sack him/her. Just like your board would fire you for poor performance.
That this is even up for debate is baffling.
PS: Grandalf, so I suppose the stock people receive in your project 'Dandelion Labs' do not really have any worth because two years down the line the people canget disposed if the founder needs to free some stock without getting diluted
I'm not making an argument here, just comparing the situation with a Trolley problem and wondering what details are most troublesome for people.
I think it was probably a stupid decision by Pincus to do this, but not necessarily an unethical one. ISOs with a vesting period are not money in the bank, and anyone who thinks of them that way has been foolish.
I have no idea why you're bringing some contorted-beyond-recognition Trolley problem into this.
The situation is more like:
1) Founder hires an employee at a depressed salary using the possibility of making it big via vested options to compensate for lost income.
2) Employee works first, second, and third years performing to satisfaction.
3) Before IPO, founder goes "I can make that employee give up their money through a threat of firing them."
Actually, isn't that pretty much the situation?
If we really want to talk analogies, it's like if someone took a health insurance policy, but when they get really sick and the "big payout," the insurance company cuts them off because they haven't contributed enough to merit the million dollar payout.
Remember the 'useless' chef already got you to where you are presently. The place where you need to raise more money.
Why then did you hire the chef in the first place? If the chef has started cooking poorly, you sack him/her. Just like your board would fire you for poor performance.
That this is even up for debate is baffling.
PS: Grandalf, so I suppose the stock people receive in your project 'Dandelion Labs' do not really have any worth because two years down the line the people canget disposed if the founder needs to free some stock without getting diluted