Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You are vastly overstating the difficulty of pivoting X11 access to complete system compromise with the "somehow gets all the right details to work" phrase. It's trivial.

People have literally gotten killed because of this type of attack. Yes, hostile nation-states probably don't care enough about you personally, but there are people for whom this is a life-and-death matter.

The one thing that reduces the impact of this is that it's Firefox on Linux, which is a niche browser on a niche OS, but desktop Linux Firefox is a product that Mozilla officially ships, which means that it's Mozilla's responsibility to protect its users.



> It's hard to overstate how much of a benefit this is in terms of security for those on Linux.

I assumed you talked about "those on Linux", not "those on Linux who have non-negligible probability of being targeted by hostile nation-states".

It's often difficult to step back and re-evaluate initial claims, and we sometimes choose to use tactics like zooming in on improbable contexts to justify them. But I think it's healthy to face criticism that may snap us out of it, so I'm writing this comment. But it's late now, so I will not be able to follow up anymore.

P.S. I don't have GNOME installed :)


Nation states aren't the only threat. There are billion dollar organized crime and fraud networks that have the means to both collect, and successfully weaponize, such RCEs.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: