> Compare: Throw the whole population of your country in prison.
That's not a comparison to the situation in Guantanamo. 780 people were detained there, out of a potential 400 million (depending on where you draw the borders).
> Nobody should be rewarded for that.
One strike, you're out? Is that the rule you judge by?
Are 780 people, of which only 8% were actually "bad", "one strike"? Not to mention even most of the "bad" ones were not tried or given a due process, and most were tortured.
That's not a comparison to the situation in Guantanamo. 780 people were detained there, out of a potential 400 million (depending on where you draw the borders).
> Nobody should be rewarded for that.
One strike, you're out? Is that the rule you judge by?