Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's a great article, and an interesting new colour space. It would be really interesting to see a variety of image transformations done in each of these colour spaces, on a variety of images (photos in particular). E.g. resizing and blurring as jiggawatts suggests, and also things like brightness, contrast, saturation, white-balance, etc.

How big are your datasets? Would the parameters get better if they were bigger, or have they converged to some optimum?

A couple of typos I spotted: "asses", "he final".



Yeah, would be nice. I've been thinking a bit about following up with that.

The generated dataset consists of a few thousand colors. The hue dataset is using 15 different hues only. Some more data there could definitely be useful.

I think the biggest problem is that there isn't that much experimental data overall, especially for wide gamut colors. The hue data is from experiments with sRGB displays if I remember correctly, and CIECAM I think has mostly been derived based on surface paints, which makes it fairly limited.

Comprehensive experiments done using modern calibrated wide gamut displays would be fantastic.

Thanks, will have a look at the typos!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: