Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Thinkpad = Linux these days sadly...

Any other laptop will boot linux, but you'll end up with a lot of rough edges...

For example, on the laptop I'm typing this on (latest Ubuntu, old Acer 511G):

* Random hangs every few days - some unpatched processor bug related to sleep states.

* Wifi diconnects randomly.

* Hotkeys don't work

* Screen sometimes dims itself to zero, and since the hotkeys don't work, it's rather tricky to fix.

* Bluetooth doesn't work

* Hibernate and sleep are disabled by default and you have to go into a config file to enable them. SD card doesn't work after sleeping more than 3 times.

* Fans don't work at all. System throttles almost immediately under any load.

* There must be some issue with the SSD losing writes because even journaled ext4 seems to get data corruption after an unclean poweroff.

* External monitors don't support hdmi audio.

* of the 3 USB ports, 2 don't work for anything more than charging devices.

* webcam LED state seems random, and does not correlate to webcam usage at all.

All on one device!

Linux on Thinkpad is great. Linux on any other hardware that core kernel devs don't use day to day is almost unusable due to these thousands of rough edges.



> Linux on any other hardware that core kernel devs don't use day to day is almost unusable due to these thousands of rough edges.

Running on 2 old Dells and an Asus with no problems (Ubuntu 18.04, upgraded in place from 16.04). Your statement is absurd on its face just based on its generality.

Of the things you've listed, I can't say anything about external HDMI audio because I don't have one, and the default hibernate thing I can confirm. Every other one I've never had, much less daily.


From personal experience, I've only had that many issues once on a bleeding edge MSI. It took about a month to work out the issues. Every other system I've used has had a much smaller subset of those issues (I'm not using a Thinkpad). Namely Bluetooth or the fans not working, and individually resolvable.


I use Linux on a dell e6400, I'm not a kernel dev, it's completely fine. Same with several other laptops I've owned.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: