Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Of course no social media company will be shut down over this. Trump couldn't shut down Twitter even if he wanted to.


The US Government could easily bankrupt Twitter. I doubt the Trump Administration is smart enough to figure out how to do this, but here is how easy it would be.

Twitter frequently selectively enforces its own terms of service. They punish some users and then intentionally let other users get away with atrocious behavior with no consequences. I've witnessed this across hundreds of various Twitter accounts over the last several years, so the number of times this happens must be rather epic. Numerous agencies of the US Government can choose to pursue Twitter for that. Twitter will find it impossible to correct their chaotic, selective, biased approach to how they treat their users so very differently. Angency N from the government slaps Twitter with an increasing fine each time they fail to properly, equitably enforce their terms of service. Start at $100 million and double it with every violation. Twitter will be bankrupt before a month is out.

Twitter would get on their knees and beg for mercy almost instantly. The US Government can break any corporation it wants to, anytime it wants to.

If the Trump Admin wants to be really devious, Nixonian, they'll target the executives operating the companies. Sending the IRS & Co. to make their lives a living hell. These companies will capitulate instantly.

Just ask the PRISM companies how this works in reality: you have no choice but to bow. It all depends on how nasty the Feds are prepared to get.


And the courts would strike down all of that. Even the ultra conservative judges.

And on top of that would force the government to pay for Twitter's legal fees. And probably also for economic damages.


The end result would be a non-US company taking Twitter's place.

Then the US Gov't would be back at square one. Only worse.


One would expect that if this happened Twitter would just cease US operations and move everything outside US Govt. jurisdiction?





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: