Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | heratyian's commentslogin

If tariffs are bad, why does every country tariff US-made products so heavily?

Maybe you have been fed a lie?

In most free trade agreements many products are without tariffs, some have quotas and others yet have tariff. For example, under CUSMA Canada have no tariffs on US made apparel and footwear, diary is under quota and steel has 25-50% tariffs. But then if you hear someone who lies a lot and has an agenda they will only tell you about steel tariffs and make you think that all US made products are under tariff.


So why is there a 25-50% tariff on steel?

> If tariffs are bad, why does every country tariff US-made products so heavily?

That's an easy question. The answer is "they don't."

USMCA/NAFTA guaranteed free trade with Mexico and Canada.

Pre-2025, there was no blanket tariff on US goods in Europe. They tariffed some agricultural goods at 11%. Industrial goods were in single digits.

The tariff numbers that Trump purports (e.g. blanket 30% tariffs on Switzerland) are in no way proportional to their tariffs on US goods. It's just false.

The lie that other countries had massive blanket tariffs on all US goods is being sold to the American public to justify massive so-called "reciprocal" tariffs that (a) violate existing trade agreements, (b) make things expense for the American consumer, (c) don't necessary encourage new businesses in the US.


> justify massive so-called "reciprocal" tariffs

I just want to point out that this "reciprocal" nonsense was in no way calculated or strategic. The chart/table they showed was literally LLM-generated and no one could explain how they got those numbers. It's a complete circus and we're sitting here refuting bullshit everyday.


> no one could explain how they got those numbers.

Not quite. The big board percentages were effectively us (imports - exports) / imports * 0.5 ~ fuzzy adjustment based on feels. Your point remains theyre amateurish and bely a lack of any grounding to actual foreign import duties. But that is a direct way of representing a mercantilist world view where net imports bad, exports strong.

https://www.investopedia.com/trade-experts-question-trump-te...


> The tariff numbers that Trump purports

Trump also either purposely or stupidly considers the VAT a tariff instead of a sales tax.


Well that's the big question. Do they? Like, why was a 15% tariff imposed to products from here in the EU? And why was Trump toying with the idea of imposing extra tariffs on my homeland of Finland alongside Denmark, Norway, Sweden, France, the UK, Germany, and the Netherlands for sending troops onto Greenland -- after having insulted the whole lot of us -- and of course also to France for daring to not join Trump's little "Board of Peace".

Even if there were massive tariffs towards the US, these are clearly politically motivated economic attacks, not motivated by economics. And that's not a thing an ally would do, regardless.


They didn't. Not until Trump started tariffing them. (I don't have time to find references, but Paul Krugman has you covered for data and analysis.)

All Trump's policies assume he's playing a single-move game where his is the only move. It turns out it's an infinite game and the other side actually has free will and competent decision makers. He can't just wish people into the cornfield as he promised.


hoping for game boy pocket...


Wow. I didn't know there was long term beef with the University of Illinois.


There have also been major protests in Panama City recently that have disrupted rails operations. https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2023/11/30/panama-celebrat...


I visited their corporate HQ in Omaha last summer. No signs on the building. No indication it's one of the most valuable companies in the world.


It is your responsibility to be physically, mentally, and financially healthy. Do what you need to do to make that happen. Can't support wife, kids, and parents if you're dead.


SEEKING WORK - Freelance/Contract - Remote/Chicago, IL

I am a full stack web developer. I can handle end-to-end web development from concept to production.

I really enjoy using Ruby on Rails, React, and Typescript. I've also worked with a variety of technologies including Python, .NET C#, and iOS swift. I have deep experience with stripe payment integrations (and stripe connect, their marketplace product). I can also help get to the first page of google search results.

A couple of projects I've built recently: - https://popping.live - https://biggreen.company

Email: ian@biggreen.company


crazy idea. let's just give our employees money.


What problem does it solve for your customers? Focus on that. If it solves their problem, it wont matter that it's a work in progress.


This could be helpful for debugging/refactoring legacy spaghetti code.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: